Adjusting to New Supply Chain Paradigms: An Analysis of the KPMG Supply Chain Survey

For decades, just-in-time (JIT) manufacturing has been the benchmark for operational efficiency. This approach emphasizes delivering products in the fastest, most cost-effective manner while maintaining a highly visible platform for continuous improvement. JIT supply chains minimize resources—such as space, inventory, and workflows—to essential levels, reducing waste and enabling organizations to convert efforts into revenue with remarkable efficiency. By eliminating excess inventory, redundant systems, and systemic bottlenecks, JIT has become a cornerstone of modern manufacturing operations.

However, the very principles that make JIT efficient also render it vulnerable. Thin operational margins mean that even minor disruptions can trigger cascading failures, with costs that far exceed the initial issue. The global expansion of supply chains amplifies this fragility, as disruptions in one region can ripple across interconnected operations, often separated by vast distances.

A Shift Toward Strategic Reshoring

Recognizing the limitations of JIT manufacturing, many organizations are now exploring a new paradigm: strategic reshoring. The recent KPMG survey of 250 executive leaders sheds light on this trend, analyzing how retooling supply chains can balance cost efficiency and resilience in volatile market conditions.

According to the survey, 81% of respondents have either completed or are in the process of relocating their U.S.-servicing supply chains to the Americas. This shift aims to streamline operations by establishing supply routes that begin and end on the continent, leveraging regional proximity to mitigate risks associated with traditional markets. For instance, volatile trade relations with China and new localized tax incentives are prompting companies to explore closer alternatives.

Traditionally, the wage gap between China and the Americas offered a substantial cost advantage for overseas manufacturing. Over the past decade, however, this gap has narrowed significantly, creating near parity with many regions in North and South America. Combined with the ability to capitalize on local incentives, this emerging stability makes reshoring an appealing option for reducing reliance on distant, risk-prone markets.

Shorter Supply Chains Enhance Resilience

Long, interconnected international supply chains are increasingly seen as fragile, with numerous points of failure and complex regulatory requirements. In contrast, reshoring promotes a shift from the "just-in-time" model to a "just-in-case" approach. This new strategy incorporates strategic reserves and local cost-saving opportunities to offset the higher inventory and operating expenses associated with reshoring.

Despite its benefits, regulatory complexity remains the primary obstacle to successful reshoring initiatives. Overhauling entrenched systems and establishing new regional operations require navigating intricate regulatory frameworks. Even organizations with robust supply chain resources face significant challenges in ensuring compliance across the chain.

Advances in data analytics, including regtech, process mapping, and risk management software, are pivotal to overcoming reshoring challenges. These tools enable organizations to address regulatory and risk management hurdles comprehensively. By leveraging robust data analytics capabilities, companies can assess cost-benefit ratios, streamline compliance efforts, and reduce friction in regulatory change management.

Strengthening the Core

The COVID-19 pandemic, strained East-West trade relations, heightened geopolitical risks, and other factors have exposed vulnerabilities in global supply chains. These challenges highlight the need for supply chains that are not only efficient but also resilient. Organizations are now focusing on strengthening their operational cores by balancing efficiency with robustness, utilizing local resources, and adopting advanced technologies to safeguard against future disruptions.

The KPMG survey underscores a pivotal shift in supply chain strategy as businesses adapt to a world fraught with uncertainty. Strategic reshoring marks a departure from the efficiency-centric JIT model, favoring a more balanced approach that prioritizes resilience and flexibility. By bringing supply chains closer to home, companies can reduce risks, simplify regulatory compliance, and seize local opportunities.

However, the transition is not without its hurdles, particularly in managing costs and navigating regulatory complexities. Data analytics emerges as a key tool in this transformation, enabling organizations to make informed decisions and optimize their reshoring efforts. As the "just-in-case" model takes hold, businesses that embrace these changes and invest in resilient supply chain frameworks will be better positioned to thrive in a dynamic global market.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.