ESA's Report Highlights Challenges and Gains in Sustainable Finance Disclosure

The European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) have just dropped a comprehensive look into how financial firms are handling Principal Adverse Impact (PAI) disclosures under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR). This 2024 report shows progress on some fronts but also highlights areas where firms are falling short on compliance and best practices. For risk and compliance pros, this report sheds light on what firms are up against in meeting sustainability reporting standards and offers practical insights into how compliance frameworks are shifting to keep up with rising regulatory demands.

The SFDR, in effect since March 2021, requires Financial Market Participants (FMPs) to be transparent about the environmental and social impacts of their investments. For firms with over 500 employees, this means submitting entity-level PAI disclosures, while smaller players may instead explain why they’re opting out. This year’s report builds on earlier ESA's analyses, covering disclosures from January 1 to December 31, 2022, and evaluating the mandated SFDR Delegated Regulation template that came into play in January 2023. Alongside an assessment of current disclosures, the report identifies best and worst practices across the industry, setting the stage for refining future compliance strategies.

There’s encouraging news: disclosures are becoming clearer and easier for investors to access. Firms, especially those tied to larger financial groups, are working to align sustainability information with accessibility standards, making disclosures more visible and user-friendly. More financial products are now meeting SFDR's PAI disclosure requirements, reflecting a broader shift toward transparent sustainable investment reporting. However, compliance gaps remain. Many firms, particularly smaller ones, are still finding it difficult to fully align with SFDR's PAI indicators. In some cases, voluntary disclosures—which ideally should spell out the firm's sustainability impact approach—end up being vague or incomplete, leaving compliance teams to bridge the gaps as best they can.

To improve industry-wide compliance, the ESA's report highlights a few best practices:

• Clarity in Disclosures: Firms that provide clear, straightforward explanations of their PAI considerations tend to do better. Disclosures should transparently cover how investments impact both environmental and social factors.
• Quantifiable Data: Compliance officers are encouraged to integrate measurable data in disclosures, giving investors a clearer picture of specific PAI indicators and the tangible impact of sustainability commitments.
• Risk-Based Compliance: When full compliance is challenging, a risk-based approach can help, focusing on meeting the most crucial regulatory requirements first.

The EBA also recommends that compliance teams at FMPs partner closely with their National Competent Authorities (NCAs) to fortify their PAI disclosures. This collaboration has been particularly useful for firms still getting up to speed with SFDR requirements and can help build a proactive compliance culture.

Looking forward, the ESA's has advised the European Commission to consider spreading out these PAI reports to ease the compliance burden, enabling firms and regulators to focus on quality over quantity. This staggered timeline would foster a more impactful compliance effort, allowing for deeper accuracy in data and more meaningful impact measurement.

In addition to timing, the ESA's hints at the need for streamlined guidelines that prioritize relevant, high-quality data rather than overwhelming volume. This would be a welcome shift for compliance and risk professionals, who are already juggling the dual challenge of regulatory adherence and delivering insights that genuinely reflect a firm’s sustainability efforts.

The ESA’s findings highlight just how crucial compliance teams are in guiding financial firms towards SFDR compliance. As regulatory demands keep ramping up, firms that can offer clear, measurable, and transparent disclosures on their sustainability impacts will likely stand out—earning trust and differentiating themselves in the eyes of both regulators and investors.

A Unified Access to Data: How the ESAP Enhances Transparency for SFDR Compliance

The European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) have recently taken a significant step towards enhancing transparency and access to financial and sustainability data through the European Single Access Point (ESAP). This system, anticipated to become operational in 2026, aims to centralize financial and sustainability information, making it more accessible for firms, regulators, and investors alike. The ESAs have published the Final Report on implementing technical standards (ITS), outlining how collection bodies will operate and how the ESAP platform itself will function.

The ESAP will be structured as a two-tier system. Entities will first submit information to designated "collection bodies" such as Officially Appointed Mechanisms (OAMs), EU agencies, or national authorities, which will validate and standardize the data before making it available on the ESAP. The new ITS set requirements for these collection bodies, including timelines for data submission, validation checks, and metadata specifications, ensuring the information meets consistent quality standards before reaching the ESAP.

From the user’s perspective, the ITS also clarify the functionalities that the ESAP will offer, such as categorization by industry and entity size, data identifiers, and types of information to be included. Importantly, the ESAP will offer a public API, providing data users, including financial and compliance professionals, with direct access to the information, streamlining due diligence and risk assessment processes by centralizing all relevant data in one platform.

Expected to play a crucial role in the EU’s Savings and Investments Union, the ESAP is poised to become a go-to resource for accessing financial and sustainability data. As firms prepare for the gradual rollout starting in July 2026, the EBA’s continued oversight, along with EIOPA and ESMA, will be instrumental in ensuring this data hub meets both user needs and regulatory standards, promising a future where compliance information is more transparent and accessible across Europe.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.