Fifth Circuit Halts SEC Climate Disclosure Rules: Preparation Still Vital for Compliance Professionals

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has issued an administrative stay of the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) much-discussed climate disclosure rule. This rule, which was unveiled on March 6, 2024, aimed to compel public companies to provide enhanced disclosures regarding the risks they encounter due to climate change.

The administrative stay was granted by a three-judge panel consisting of Judges Jones, Higginson, and Wilson, the majority of whom were appointed by Republican presidents. However, notably absent from the order was any substantive legal reasoning. Instead, the decision simply states that the petitioners' motion for an administrative stay has been granted, leaving the broader implications and reasoning behind the ruling open to speculation.

Effectively, this decision puts the enforcement and applicability of the SEC's climate disclosure rule on hold until the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals can thoroughly evaluate its constitutional and statutory validity. It's essential to recognize, however, that this action does not constitute a definitive judgment on the rule's legitimacy. Rather, it initiates a process whereby the court will engage in more extensive legal deliberations to determine its fate.

The petition for review that prompted this action was filed by a pair of energy companies, echoing arguments against the SEC's climate disclosure rule previously voiced in public comments and by Republican SEC Commissioners. These arguments primarily assert that the rule breaches the major questions doctrine, lacks substantial evidence, and infringes upon First Amendment rights. It's anticipated that these contentions will take center stage in subsequent legal proceedings, potentially influencing not only the fate of this specific rule but also shaping future regulatory endeavors.

With numerous lawsuits challenging the SEC climate disclosure rule across various Courts of Appeal, including the Second, Sixth, Eighth, Eleventh, and D.C. circuits, the procedural roadmap moving forward remains unclear. Any of these appellate courts could ultimately preside over the challenge to the rule. Until a conclusive ruling emerges, the SEC climate disclosure rule stands stayed by the Fifth Circuit.

Reacting to the news, a federal court on Friday temporarily halted the implementation of the SEC's new rules. The decision came following objections raised by two oil and gas companies, who argued that the requirements were unduly burdensome and arbitrary.

In light of these developments, compliance professionals within public companies find themselves in a challenging position. While the immediate enforcement of the SEC's climate disclosure rule is on hold, the need for preparation and vigilance remains paramount. The outcome of the legal proceedings surrounding this rule is poised to have far-reaching implications, not only for corporate disclosure practices but also for the broader regulatory landscape concerning climate-related issues.

As the legal battle unfolds and the fate of the SEC's climate disclosure rule hangs in the balance, stakeholders across sectors will be closely monitoring developments, cognizant of the potential ramifications for corporate governance, transparency, and environmental accountability.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.