PCAOB Takes Action Against Nine Firms in KPMG Network for Audit Reporting Violations

Key Takeaways

• PCAOB Sanctions: Nine firms from KPMG’s global network have been sanctioned for violating PCAOB rules and quality control standards.
• Violations: The firms failed to properly disclose audit participants, including other accounting firms, and failed to meet communication requirements with audit committees.
• Fines and Censures: The PCAOB imposed civil penalties totaling $3.375 million and censured each firm.
• Remedial Actions: Each firm is required to implement corrective actions to improve quality control practices.

Deep Dive

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has taken action against nine firms from KPMG's network for failing to meet essential regulatory requirements. The sanctions come as a direct response to violations of key reporting rules and quality control standards, and send a clear message about the PCAOB’s commitment to safeguarding the integrity of the financial system.

The firms—spanning across KPMG's global presence, including Brazil, Italy, Israel, the UK, Mexico, South Korea, Switzerland, and Autralia—were each found guilty of failing to disclose critical details about who was involved in audits. This oversight has far-reaching implications, as it leaves investors and audit committees without full visibility into the audit process, undermining their ability to make well-informed decisions.

A Lack of Transparency in Audit Reporting
The violations are centered around a fundamental requirement for audit transparency: accurate reporting of all participants in an audit. Under PCAOB Rule 3211, firms are required to disclose who performed audits, particularly when multiple accounting firms contribute to the work. This is especially crucial in cross-border audits, where numerous firms might be involved. The failure to meet these reporting obligations means that the full scope of who conducted the audit is left unclear, hindering oversight and decision-making for investors and audit committees alike.

KPMG's firms across several regions—namely Australia, Brazil, Canada, and the UK—also faltered in their communication with audit committees. These failures went beyond simply not reporting who was involved. Some of the firms failed to share key information about the planned roles of other firms, creating gaps in the audit committee's ability to properly supervise the audit process. In an environment where transparency is paramount, these shortcomings are a critical misstep.

KPMG Brazil, in particular, found itself in hot water for additional violations. In an even more concerning breach of PCAOB regulations, the firm neglected to file essential audit reports and consents on its annual filings (Form 2). This lack of documentation raised serious questions about KPMG Brazil’s commitment to regulatory compliance and the transparency of its audit processes.

The Sanctions and What They Mean Moving Forward
As a result of these violations, the PCAOB has imposed civil fines totaling $3.375 million, along with formal censure of each of the firms involved. But the financial penalties are only part of the story. Each firm is now required to take corrective action, overhauling their internal quality control procedures to ensure compliance with PCAOB standards going forward. This includes addressing weaknesses in audit participant disclosure and improving communication protocols with audit committees.

PCAOB Chair Erica Y. Williams made it clear that transparency is essential for maintaining the integrity of the auditing process, stating, “It is essential that investors and audit committees know where issuers’ audits are being conducted and by whom so that they can make informed selection and ratification decisions.”

For KPMG's network, this presents an opportunity to rebuild trust with investors, audit committees, and regulators. It also serves as a lesson to other firms that regulators are focused on audit transparency, and there will be consequences for those who fall short of compliance standards.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.