UK Proposes Law to Regulate ESG Ratings Providers, Aiming for Transparency & Investor Confidence

The UK government has recently unveiled draft legislation to regulate providers of these influential metrics. The proposal, which would place ESG ratings firms under the oversight of the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), reflects growing concerns about transparency and accountability in an industry that increasingly shapes global investment decisions.

The legislation comes after a year-long consultation by the UK Treasury, which revealed widespread support for regulatory oversight. Investors, businesses, and even ESG ratings providers themselves acknowledged the need for clearer rules and greater transparency to ensure ESG ratings can be trusted in guiding capital flows.

Tulip Siddiq, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, underscored the importance of this step, stating, “With the global ESG market predicted to surpass $40 trillion by 2030, investors and markets are making increasing use of ESG ratings to inform investment decisions and capital allocation. Bringing ESG ratings providers into regulation will boost investor confidence, reduce greenwashing, and address the lack of transparency.”

Why Regulation Matters

For years, ESG ratings have played a growing role in shaping how companies and investments are perceived. Yet, these ratings have largely operated outside the purview of financial regulators, raising questions about their reliability and susceptibility to conflicts of interest.

The issue is not unique to the UK. In 2021, the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) urged regulators worldwide to address these concerns, recommending measures like improved transparency in methodologies and stricter management of conflicts of interest. The EU has already taken steps, placing ESG ratings providers under the oversight of the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) and implementing rules to increase the comparability and reliability of ratings.

The UK’s draft legislation mirrors these global efforts, signaling its intention to stay competitive in the ESG space while protecting investors from misleading or opaque practices.

What’s in the Draft?

The proposed rules would require ESG ratings providers to obtain authorization from the FCA. This would involve meeting strict standards on transparency and governance, including clear disclosures of methodologies and processes for managing conflicts of interest. Crucially, the regulations would apply not only to UK-based firms but also to overseas providers whose ratings are used by UK clients.

However, some providers may be exempt from the new rules. Credit rating agencies and investment research firms already regulated by the FCA, for example, would not face additional oversight if ESG ratings are part of their broader activities rather than standalone services.

Broad Support & Long-Term Goals

The Treasury’s consultation revealed overwhelming backing for these measures. An impressive 95% of respondents supported the introduction of regulation, with 87% of ESG ratings providers agreeing that oversight was necessary. Many cited the need for greater clarity in how ESG ratings are determined and how conflicts of interest are handled.

The government has outlined a four-year plan to bring the regime into full effect. If the legislation is introduced to Parliament in early 2025 as planned, the FCA will begin developing detailed policy proposals and consulting with stakeholders. Affected firms would then go through an authorization process before the regime goes live.

While the timeline for implementation may seem protracted, it reflects the complexity of crafting rules that strike a balance between rigorous oversight and encouraging innovation in a rapidly evolving market. ESG ratings are increasingly pivotal in guiding investments, with the market projected to exceed $40 trillion by 2030. Ensuring these ratings are reliable and transparent is critical to maintaining investor confidence and supporting sustainable growth.

The draft legislation is a clear signal from the UK government that ESG ratings providers can no longer operate in a regulatory gray zone. By bringing these firms under FCA supervision, the UK aims to protect investors, bolster market integrity, and ensure that the booming ESG sector evolves in a way that supports trust and accountability.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.