Why Effective Policy Management is Non-Negotiable for Organizational Success

In the world of governance, risk management, and compliance, policies are not just procedural formalities—they are the bedrock upon which organizations build their operational integrity. Properly designed and implemented, policies ensure that processes, transactions, and behaviors align with the organization’s objectives, mitigating risks and upholding values. But as vital as they are, policies can also be a double-edged sword: when poorly managed, they expose organizations to significant legal liabilities.

At its core, a policy is a risk document. The very existence of a policy signals that there is an area of uncertainty that needs to be controlled. Policies serve as a compass, guiding organizations through the complexities of compliance with regulations, ethical standards, and contractual obligations. But when these policies are neglected or mismanaged, they become a liability rather than a safeguard, with far-reaching consequences in civil, criminal, or regulatory contexts.

The Stark Reality of Policy Mismanagement

Despite their critical role, policies are often shockingly mishandled within organizations. This is a phenomenon I've observed time and again, whether through my global Policy Management by Design workshops or the numerous research papers I've authored on the topic. My work, including the development of PolicyManagementPro.com and the Certified Policy Management Professional certification in partnership with OCEG, has highlighted several common, yet perilous, pitfalls in policy management:

• Unknown Policies: Many organizations lack a comprehensive understanding of the policies they have in place. It’s not uncommon for policies to be scattered across departments, with no master list. In one conference I spoke at, only two out of several hundred attendees could confidently say they had a complete inventory of their organization’s policies.
• Fragmented Policy Portals: The absence of a unified policy portal is a significant issue. I recall an insurance company in March 2020, during the initial pandemic lockdowns, realizing in a panic that they had 27 different portals for policy access—ranging from file shares to SharePoint sites—creating a confusing labyrinth for employees to navigate.
• Inconsistent Writing Styles and Processes: Without a standardized process or template for policy creation, policies can vary wildly in style and structure. The lack of a “Policy on Writing Policies” (or Metapolicy) and a style guide leads to inconsistency, which can undermine the clarity and enforceability of policies.
• Rogue Policies: A particularly insidious problem is the creation of unauthorized policies by managers who, perhaps well-intentioned, draft documents and label them as policies without proper vetting or approval. These rogue policies can create significant legal liabilities if not properly managed and aligned with the organization’s official stance.
• Outdated and Irrelevant Policies: Policies that remain on the books indefinitely without regular review and updates can become obsolete or counterproductive. They may no longer reflect current laws, regulations, or business practices, leading to confusion and potential non-compliance.
• Lagging Behind Regulatory and Business Changes: Organizations often struggle to keep policies up-to-date with rapidly changing regulatory environments. For example, one bank took six months to update a policy due to a cumbersome review process involving 75 different stakeholders. In a world where hundreds of regulatory changes occur daily, such delays are untenable.
• Inadequate Response to Employee Changes: As employees move within an organization, there is often a disconnect in ensuring they are aware of the policies relevant to their new roles. This is especially critical in high-risk areas, where ignorance of applicable policies can have serious repercussions.
• Lack of Audit Trails and System of Record: In the current legal and regulatory landscape, having a defensible audit trail for policy communication and employee training is essential. The U.S. Department of Justice, for example, places significant emphasis on this in its Evaluation of Compliance Programs. Without a clear record, organizations leave themselves vulnerable to legal challenges, as seen in high-profile cases like Morgan Stanley.
• Outdated Policy Portals and Training Systems: Modern employees, particularly Millennials and Gen Z, expect seamless, integrated digital experiences. Yet many organizations still rely on outdated systems where policies and training are siloed in different platforms. The need for mobility and accessibility is critical—employees should be able to access and engage with policies from any device, anywhere, just as easily as they navigate social media.

The Path Forward: Holistic Policy Management

Given the multitude of ways policy management can fail, organizations must approach the task with both a back-office and front-office perspective:

• Back-Office Policy Management: This involves establishing a consistent, enterprise-wide process for policy creation, approval, monitoring, enforcement, and auditing. Collaboration across departments, supported by robust technology, is key to ensuring that nothing falls through the cracks. Adhering to a Metapolicy and using standardized templates is crucial for maintaining consistency and clarity.
• Front-Office Policy Engagement: This is where policies come to life for employees and third parties. A singular, user-friendly portal that integrates policies and training is essential. Regular reminders, accessible training, and clear communication are all part of ensuring that employees are not just aware of, but also understand and adhere to the policies that govern their roles.

The importance of effective policy management cannot be overstated. Without well-crafted and well-enforced policies, organizations are adrift—vulnerable to legal liabilities, regulatory penalties, and operational chaos. Addressing both the back-office mechanics and the front-office engagement of policy management is not just a best practice; it’s a necessity for any organization committed to governance, risk management, and compliance.

In short, it’s time to treat policies with the respect they deserve. After all, they are the framework that keeps the organizational house in order, ensuring that it withstands the inevitable winds of change and uncertainty.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.